eLife · Jun 2024
John J Maurer, Alexandra Lin, Xi Jin, … Shinjae Chung
Abstract
Rapid eye movement sleep (REMs) is characterized by activated electroencephalogram (EEG) and muscle atonia, accompanied by vivid dreams. REMs is homeostatically regulated, ensuring that any loss of REMs is compensated by a subsequent increase in its amount. However, the neural mechanisms underlying the homeostatic control of REMs are largely unknown. Here, we show that GABAergic neurons in the preoptic area of the hypothalamus projecting to the tuberomammillary nucleus (POA GAD2 →TMN neurons) are crucial for the homeostatic regulation of REMs in mice. POA GAD2 →TMN neurons are most active during REMs, and inhibiting them specifically decreases REMs. REMs restriction leads to an increased number and amplitude of calcium transients in POA GAD2 →TMN neurons, reflecting the accumulation of REMs pressure. Inhibiting POA GAD2 →TMN neurons during REMs restriction blocked the subsequent rebound of REMs. Our findings reveal a hypothalamic circuit whose activity mirrors the buildup of homeostatic REMs pressure during restriction and that is required for the ensuing rebound in REMs.
Nature · Jun 2024
Belgin Yalçın, Matthew B. Pomrenze, Karen Malacon, … Michelle Monje
Abstract
All drugs of abuse induce long-lasting changes in synaptic transmission and neural circuit function that underlie substance-use disorders 1,2 . Another recently appreciated mechanism of neural circuit plasticity is mediated through activity-regulated changes in myelin that can tune circuit function and influence cognitive behaviour 3–7 . Here we explore the role of myelin plasticity in dopaminergic circuitry and reward learning. We demonstrate that dopaminergic neuronal activity-regulated myelin plasticity is a key modulator of dopaminergic circuit function and opioid reward. Oligodendroglial lineage cells respond to dopaminergic neuronal activity evoked by optogenetic stimulation of dopaminergic neurons, optogenetic inhibition of GABAergic neurons, or administration of morphine. These oligodendroglial changes are evident selectively within the ventral tegmental area but not along the axonal projections in the medial forebrain bundle nor within the target nucleus accumbens. Genetic blockade of oligodendrogenesis dampens dopamine release dynamics in nucleus accumbens and impairs behavioural conditioning to morphine. Taken together, these findings underscore a critical role for oligodendrogenesis in reward learning and identify dopaminergic neuronal activity-regulated myelin plasticity as an important circuit modification that is required for opioid reward.
Science Advances · May 2024
Eric Garr, Yifeng Cheng, Huijeong Jeong, … Patricia H. Janak
Abstract
Learning causal relationships relies on understanding how often one event precedes another. To investigate how dopamine neuron activity and neurotransmitter release change when a retrospective relationship is degraded for a specific pair of events, we used outcome-selective Pavlovian contingency degradation in rats. Conditioned responding was attenuated for the cue-reward contingency that was degraded, as was dopamine neuron activity in the midbrain and dopamine release in the ventral striatum in response to the cue and subsequent reward. Contingency degradation also abolished the trial-by-trial history dependence of the dopamine responses at the time of trial outcome. This profile of changes in cue- and reward-evoked responding is not easily explained by a standard reinforcement learning model. An alternative model based on learning causal relationships was better able to capture dopamine responses during contingency degradation, as well as conditioned behavior following optogenetic manipulations of dopamine during noncontingent rewards. Our results suggest that mesostriatal dopamine encodes the contingencies between meaningful events during learning.
Nature · May 2024
Fabrice Chaudun, Laurena Python, Yu Liu, … Christian Lüscher
Abstract
Fentanyl is a powerful painkiller that elicits euphoria and positive reinforcement 1 . Fentanyl also leads to dependence, defined by the aversive withdrawal syndrome, which fuels negative reinforcement 2,3 (that is, individuals retake the drug to avoid withdrawal). Positive and negative reinforcement maintain opioid consumption, which leads to addiction in one-fourth of users, the largest fraction for all addictive drugs 4 . Among the opioid receptors, µ-opioid receptors have a key role 5 , yet the induction loci of circuit adaptations that eventually lead to addiction remain unknown. Here we injected mice with fentanyl to acutely inhibit γ-aminobutyric acid-expressing neurons in the ventral tegmental area (VTA), causing disinhibition of dopamine neurons, which eventually increased dopamine in the nucleus accumbens. Knockdown of µ-opioid receptors in VTA abolished dopamine transients and positive reinforcement, but withdrawal remained unchanged. We identified neurons expressing µ-opioid receptors in the central amygdala (CeA) whose activity was enhanced during withdrawal. Knockdown of µ-opioid receptors in CeA eliminated aversive symptoms, suggesting that they mediate negative reinforcement. Thus, optogenetic stimulation caused place aversion, and mice readily learned to press a lever to pause optogenetic stimulation of CeA neurons that express µ-opioid receptors. Our study parses the neuronal populations that trigger positive and negative reinforcement in VTA and CeA, respectively. We lay out the circuit organization to develop interventions for reducing fentanyl addiction and facilitating rehabilitation.
Nature Communications · May 2024
Lauren Faget, Lucie Oriol, Wen-Chun Lee, … Thomas S. Hnasko
Abstract
The ventral pallidum (VP) contains GABA and glutamate neurons projecting to ventral tegmental area (VTA) whose stimulation drives approach and avoidance, respectively. Yet little is known about the mechanisms by which VP cell types shape VTA activity and drive behavior. Here, we found that both VP GABA and glutamate neurons were activated during approach to reward or by delivery of an aversive stimulus. Stimulation of VP GABA neurons inhibited VTA GABA, but activated dopamine and glutamate neurons. Remarkably, stimulation-evoked activation was behavior-contingent such that VTA recruitment was inhibited when evoked by the subject’s own action. Conversely, VP glutamate neurons activated VTA GABA, as well as dopamine and glutamate neurons, despite driving aversion. However, VP glutamate neurons evoked dopamine in aversion-associated ventromedial nucleus accumbens (NAc), but reduced dopamine release in reward-associated dorsomedial NAc. These findings show how heterogeneous VP projections to VTA can be engaged to shape approach and avoidance behaviors.
Science Advances · Apr 2024
Ben Rein, Kendall Raymond, Cali Boustani, … Robert C. Malenka
Abstract
MDMA (3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine) is a psychoactive drug with powerful prosocial effects. While MDMA is sometimes termed an “empathogen,” empirical studies have struggled to clearly demonstrate these effects or pinpoint underlying mechanisms. Here, we paired the social transfer of pain and analgesia—behavioral tests modeling empathy in mice—with region-specific neuropharmacology, optogenetics, and transgenic manipulations to explore MDMA’s action as an empathogen. We report that MDMA, given intraperitoneally or infused directly into the nucleus accumbens (NAc), robustly enhances the social transfer of pain and analgesia. Optogenetic stimulation of 5-HT release in the NAc recapitulates the effects of MDMA, implicating 5-HT signaling as a core mechanism. Last, we demonstrate that systemic MDMA or optogenetic stimulation of NAc 5-HT inputs restores deficits in empathy-like behaviors in the Shank3- deficient mouse model of autism. These findings demonstrate enhancement of empathy-related behaviors by MDMA and implicate 5-HT signaling in the NAc as a core mechanism mediating MDMA’s empathogenic effects.
Research Square · Apr 2024
Benjamin De Corte, Youngcho Kim, Kelsey Heslin, … Peter Balsam
Abstract
Photometry and electrophysiology are powerful tools for investigating brain-behavior relationships. Combining these techniques would allow us to ask previously un-addressable questions, such as how neuromodulators impact neuronal firing rates. Current options are highly limited—requiring a substantial loss in data-quality or severely restricting naturalistic-movement. These drawbacks arise from engineering-limits on devices that allow optically-tethered subjects to move freely. Here, we introduce a device that overcomes these challenges. Its automated orientation-tracking system allows subjects to move freely for multiple-hours with minimal supervision and without sacrificing data-quality. The device is modular and adaptable, being compatible with most recording systems and equipped for added functionality (e.g., optogenetics). To demonstrate its utility, we simultaneously tracked extracellular striatal dopamine and single-neuron firing as mice performed a reward-learning task. Mice showed excellent mobility, and we observed robust trial-by-trial correlations between striatal firing and dopamine signaling. This device provides a powerful tool that outperforms current commercial solutions.
bioRxiv · Feb 2024
Robyn St. Laurent, Kelly M Kusche, Anatol C Kreitzer, Robert C Malenka
Abstract
Background The avoidance of aversive stimuli due to negative reinforcement learning is critical for survival in real-world environments, which demand dynamic responding to both positive and negative stimuli that often conflict with each other. Individuals with obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) commonly exhibit impaired negative reinforcement and extinction, perhaps involving deficits in amygdala functioning. An amygdala subregion of particular interest is the intercalated nuclei of the amygdala (ITC) which has been linked to negative reinforcement and extinction, with distinct clusters mediating separate aspects of behavior. This study focuses on the dorsal ITC cluster (ITC d ) and its role in negative reinforcement during a complex behavior that models real-world dynamic decision making. Methods We investigated the impact of ITC d function on negative reinforcement and extinction by applying fiber photometry measurement of GCamp6f signals and optogenetic manipulations during a platform-mediated avoidance task in a mouse model of OCD-like behavior: the Sapap3 -null mouse. Results We find impaired neural activity in the ITC d of male and female Sapap3 -null mice to the encoding of negative stimuli during platform-mediated avoidance. Sapap3 -null mice also exhibit deficits in extinction of avoidant behavior, which is modulated by ITC d neural activity. Conclusions Sapap3 -null mice fail to extinguish avoidant behavior in platform-mediated avoidance, due to heightened ITC d activity. This deficit can be rescued by optogenetically inhibiting ITC d during extinction. Together, our results provide insight into the neural mechanisms underpinning negative reinforcement deficits in the context of OCD, emphasizing the necessity of ITC d in responding to negative stimuli in complex environments.
Cell Reports · 2024
Dakota Palmer, Christelle A. Cayton, Alexandra Scott, … Jocelyn M. Richard
Abstract
Reward-predictive cues acquire motivating and reinforcing properties that contribute to the escalation and relapse of drug use in addiction. The ventral pallidum (VP) and ventral tegmental area (VTA) are two key nodes in brain reward circuitry implicated in addiction and cue-driven behavior. In the current study, we use in vivo fiber photometry and optogenetics to record from and manipulate VP→VTA in rats performing a discriminative stimulus task to determine the role these neurons play in invigoration and reinforcement by reward cues. We find that VP→VTA neurons are active during reward consumption and that optogenetic stimulation of these neurons biases choice behavior and is reinforcing. Critically, we find no encoding of reward-seeking vigor, and optogenetic stimulation does not enhance the probability or vigor of reward seeking in response to cues. Our results suggest that VP→VTA activity is more important for reinforcement than for invigoration of reward seeking by cues.
bioRxiv · Dec 2023
Tara J. Aitken, Truong Ly, Sarah Shehata, … Zachary A. Knight
Abstract
The rewarding taste of food is critical for motivating animals to eat, but whether taste has a parallel function in promoting meal termination is not well understood. Here we show that hunger-promoting AgRP neurons are rapidly inhibited during each bout of ingestion by a signal linked to the taste of food. Blocking these transient dips in activity via closed-loop optogenetic stimulation increases food intake by selectively delaying the onset of satiety. We show that upstream leptin receptor-expressing neurons in the dorsomedial hypothalamus (DMH LepR ) are tuned to respond to sweet or fatty tastes and exhibit time-locked activation during feeding that is the mirror image of downstream AgRP cells. These findings reveal an unexpected role for taste in the negative feedback control of ingestion. They also reveal a mechanism by which AgRP neurons, which are the primary cells that drive hunger, are able to influence the moment-by-moment dynamics of food consumption.
Nature · Nov 2023
Truong Ly, Jun Y. Oh, Nilla Sivakumar, … Zachary A. Knight
Abstract
The termination of a meal is controlled by dedicated neural circuits in the caudal brainstem. A key challenge is to understand how these circuits transform the sensory signals generated during feeding into dynamic control of behaviour. The caudal nucleus of the solitary tract (cNTS) is the first site in the brain where many meal-related signals are sensed and integrated 1–4 , but how the cNTS processes ingestive feedback during behaviour is unknown. Here we describe how prolactin-releasing hormone (PRLH) and GCG neurons, two principal cNTS cell types that promote non-aversive satiety, are regulated during ingestion. PRLH neurons showed sustained activation by visceral feedback when nutrients were infused into the stomach, but these sustained responses were substantially reduced during oral consumption. Instead, PRLH neurons shifted to a phasic activity pattern that was time-locked to ingestion and linked to the taste of food. Optogenetic manipulations revealed that PRLH neurons control the duration of seconds-timescale feeding bursts, revealing a mechanism by which orosensory signals feed back to restrain the pace of ingestion. By contrast, GCG neurons were activated by mechanical feedback from the gut, tracked the amount of food consumed and promoted satiety that lasted for tens of minutes. These findings reveal that sequential negative feedback signals from the mouth and gut engage distinct circuits in the caudal brainstem, which in turn control elements of feeding behaviour operating on short and long timescales.
bioRxiv · Nov 2023
Kurt M. Fraser, Val L. Collins, Amy R. Wolff, … Benjamin T. Saunders
Abstract
Adaptive behavior in a dynamic environment often requires rapid revaluation of stimuli that deviates from well-learned associations. The divergence between stable value-encoding and appropriate behavioral output remains a critical test to theories of dopamine’s function in learning, motivation, and motor control. Yet how dopamine neurons are involved in the revaluation of cues when the world changes to alter our behavior remains unclear. Here we make use of pharmacology, in vivo electrophysiology, fiber photometry, and optogenetics to resolve the contributions of the mesolimbic dopamine system to the dynamic reorganization of reward-seeking. Male and female rats were trained to discriminate when a conditioned stimulus would be followed by sucrose reward by exploiting the prior, non-overlapping presentation of a separate discrete cue - an occasion setter. Only when the occasion setter’s presentation preceded the conditioned stimulus did the conditioned stimulus predict sucrose delivery. As a result, in this task we were able to dissociate the average value of the conditioned stimulus from its immediate expected value on a trial-to-trial basis. Both the activity of ventral tegmental area dopamine neurons and dopamine signaling in the nucleus accumbens were essential for rats to successfully update behavioral responding in response to the occasion setter. Moreover, dopamine release in the nucleus accumbens following the conditioned stimulus only occurred when the occasion setter indicated it would predict reward. Downstream of dopamine release, we found that single neurons in the nucleus accumbens dynamically tracked the value of the conditioned stimulus. Together these results reveal a novel mechanism within the mesolimbic dopamine system for the rapid revaluation of motivation.
Nature Communications · Oct 2023
Marie A. Labouesse, Arturo Torres-Herraez, Muhammad O. Chohan, … Christoph Kellendonk
Abstract
In the classical model of the basal ganglia, direct pathway striatal projection neurons (dSPNs) send projections to the substantia nigra (SNr) and entopeduncular nucleus to regulate motor function. Recent studies have re-established that dSPNs also possess axon collaterals within the globus pallidus (GPe) (bridging collaterals), yet the significance of these collaterals for behavior is unknown. Here we use in vivo optical and chemogenetic tools combined with deep learning approaches in mice to dissect the roles of dSPN GPe collaterals in motor function. We find that dSPNs projecting to the SNr send synchronous motor-related information to the GPe via axon collaterals. Inhibition of native activity in dSPN GPe terminals impairs motor activity and function via regulation of Npas1 neurons. We propose a model by which dSPN GPe axon collaterals (striatopallidal Go pathway) act in concert with the canonical terminals in the SNr to support motor control by inhibiting Npas1 neurons.
Research Square · Oct 2023
Franz Weber, Jiso Hong, David Lozano, … Shinjae Chung
Abstract
Rapid-eye-movement (REM) sleep is accompanied by intense cortical activity, underlying its wake-like electroencephalogram (EEG). The neural activity inducing REM sleep is thought to originate from subcortical circuits in brainstem and hypothalamus. However, whether cortical neurons can also trigger REM sleep has remained unknown. Here, we show in mice that the medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) strongly promotes REM sleep. Bidirectional optogenetic manipulations demonstrate that excitatory mPFC neurons promote REM sleep through their projections to the lateral hypothalamus (LH) and regulate phasic events, reflected in accelerated EEG theta oscillations and increased eye-movement density during REM sleep. Calcium imaging reveals that the majority of LH-projecting mPFC neurons are maximally activated during REM sleep and a subpopulation is recruited during phasic theta accelerations. Our results delineate a cortico-hypothalamic circuit for the top-down control of REM sleep and identify a critical role of the mPFC in regulating phasic events during REM sleep.
CNS Neuroscience & Therapeutics · Sep 2023
Muhammad Asim, Huajie Wang, Xi Chen, Jufang He
Abstract
Aims Major depressive disorder is a severe psychiatric disorder that afflicts ~17% of the world population. Neuroimaging investigations of depressed patients have consistently reported the dysfunction of the basolateral amygdala in the pathophysiology of depression. However, how the BLA and related circuits are implicated in the pathogenesis of depression is poorly understood. Methods Here, we combined fiber photometry, immediate early gene expression (c‐fos), optogenetics, chemogenetics, behavioral analysis, and viral tracing techniques to provide multiple lines of evidence of how the BLA neurons mediate depressive‐like behavior. Results We demonstrated that the aversive stimuli elevated the neuronal activity of the excitatory BLA neurons (BLA CAMKII neurons). Optogenetic activation of CAMKII neurons facilitates the induction of depressive‐like behavior while inhibition of these neurons alleviates the depressive‐like behavior. Next, we found that the chemogenetic inhibition of GABAergic neurons in the BLA (BLA GABA ) increased the firing frequency of CAMKII neurons and mediates the depressive‐like phenotypes. Finally, through fiber photometry recording and chemogenetic manipulation, we proved that the activation of BLA GABA neurons inhibits BLA CAMKII neuronal activity and alleviates depressive‐like behavior in the mice. Conclusion Thus, through evaluating BLA GABA and BLA CAMKII neurons by distinct interaction, the BLA regulates depressive‐like behavior.
bioRxiv · May 2023
Dakota Palmer, Christelle A. Cayton, Alexandra Scott, … Jocelyn M. Richard
Abstract
Reward-predictive cues acquire motivating and reinforcing properties that contribute to the escalation and relapse of drug use in addiction. The ventral pallidum (VP) and ventral tegmental area (VTA) are two key nodes in brain reward circuitry implicated in addiction and necessary for the performance of cue-driven behavior. Evidence suggests that VP neurons projecting to the VTA (VP→VTA) promote cue-induced reinstatement of drug-seeking, but the mechanisms by which these neurons do so are undefined. In addition, the role of these neurons in the pursuit of non-drug reward is not known. In the current study, we used in vivo fiber photometry and optogenetics to record from and manipulate VP→VTA in rats performing a discriminative stimulus task (DS task) with sucrose reward to determine the fundamental role these neurons play in invigoration and reinforcement by reward and associated discriminative cues. We find that VP→VTA neurons are selectively active during reward consumption, that optogenetic stimulation of these neurons paired with reward consumption biases choice, and that VP→VTA optogenetic stimulation is reinforcing. Critically, we found no significant encoding of cue-elicited reward-seeking vigor and acute optogenetic stimulation of these neurons paired with cue onset did not enhance the probability or vigor of reward-seeking. Our results suggest that VP→VTA neurons are active during the consumption of natural reward and that this activity reinforces seeking behavior.
bioRxiv · Mar 2023
Ashlea A. Morgan, Nuno D. Alves, Gregory S. Stevens, … Mark S. Ansorge
Abstract
The medial prefrontal cortex (mPFC) regulates cognitive flexibility and emotional behavior. Neurons that release serotonin project to the mPFC, and serotonergic drugs influence emotion and cognition. Yet, the specific roles of endogenous serotonin release in the mPFC on neurophysiology and behavior are unknown. We show that axonal serotonin release in the mPFC directly inhibits the major mPFC output neurons. In serotonergic neurons projecting from the dorsal raphe to the mPFC, we find endogenous activity signatures pre-reward retrieval and at reward retrieval during a cognitive flexibility task. In vivo optogenetic activation of this pathway during pre-reward retrieval selectively improved extradimensional rule shift performance while inhibition impaired it, demonstrating sufficiency and necessity for mPFC serotonin release in cognitive flexibility. Locomotor activity and anxiety-like behavior were not affected by either optogenetic manipulation. Collectively, our data reveal a powerful and specific modulatory role of endogenous serotonin release from dorsal raphe-to-mPFC projecting neurons in cognitive flexibility.
Experimental Neurobiology · Dec 2022
Myungmo An, Hyun-Kyung Kim, Hoyong Park, … Sung-Yon Kim
Abstract
The lateral septum (LS) is a forebrain structure that has been implicated in a wide range of behavioral and physiological responses to stress. However, the specific populations of neurons in the LS that mediate stress responses remain incompletely understood. Here, we show that neurons in the dorsal lateral septum (LSd) that express the somatostatin gene (hereafter, LSdSst neurons) are activated by diverse stressors. Retrograde tracing from LSdSst neurons revealed that these neurons are directly innervated by neurons in the locus coeruleus (LC), the primary source of norepinephrine well-known to mediate diverse stress-related functions in the brain. Consistently, we found that norepinephrine increased excitatory synaptic transmission onto LSdSst neurons, suggesting the functional connectivity between LSdSst neurons and LC noradrenergic neurons. However, optogenetic stimulation of LSdSst neurons did not affect stress-related behaviors or autonomic functions, likely owing to the functional heterogeneity within this population. Together, our findings show that LSdSst neurons are activated by diverse stressors and suggest that norepinephrine released from the LC may modulate the activity of LSdSst neurons under stressful circumstances.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences · Nov 2022
Hanna Antila, Iris Kwak, Ashley Choi, … Shinjae Chung
Abstract
In our daily life, we are exposed to uncontrollable and stressful events that disrupt our sleep. However, the underlying neural mechanisms deteriorating the quality of non-rapid eye movement sleep (NREMs) and REM sleep are largely unknown. Here, we show in mice that acute psychosocial stress disrupts sleep by increasing brief arousals (microarousals [MAs]), reducing sleep spindles, and impairing infraslow oscillations in the spindle band of the electroencephalogram during NREMs, while reducing REMs. This poor sleep quality was reflected in an increased number of calcium transients in the activity of noradrenergic (NE) neurons in the locus coeruleus (LC) during NREMs. Opto- and chemogenetic LC-NE activation in naïve mice is sufficient to change the sleep microarchitecture similar to stress. Conversely, chemogenetically inhibiting LC-NE neurons reduced MAs during NREMs and normalized their number after stress. Specifically inhibiting LC-NE neurons projecting to the preoptic area of the hypothalamus (POA) decreased MAs and enhanced spindles and REMs after stress. Optrode recordings revealed that stimulating LC-NE fibers in the POA indeed suppressed the spiking activity of POA neurons that are activated during sleep spindles and REMs and inactivated during MAs. Our findings reveal that changes in the dynamics of the stress-regulatory LC-NE neurons during sleep negatively affect sleep quality, partially through their interaction with the POA.
bioRxiv · Nov 2022
Miguel Á. Luján, Reana Young-Morrison, Sheila A. Engi, … Joseph F. Cheer
Abstract
Drug addiction is characterized by a sustained vulnerability to relapse even after long periods of abstinence. A deeper understanding of the brain systems underlying this state could inform therapeutic strategies with novel prognostic biomarkers aimed at preventing renewed drug seeking. Most drugs of abuse, in particular psychostimulants such as cocaine, lead to long-lasting mesolimbic dopamine system adaptations, that ultimately facilitate drug seeking following exposure to drug-paired cues. This “dopaminergic hypothesis” of relapse has been previously addressed, but technical limitations in measuring in vivo dopamine release have precluded the assessment of its sufficiency without introducing pharmacological, electrical, or optogenetic confounds. Using a dopamine receptor-based fluorescent sensor in freely moving mice, we show that long-lasting dopamine recordings in the nucleus accumbens (NAc), throughout the animal’s entire history of cocaine self-administration, are strong predictors of relapse as well as the time it takes an animal to extinguish its drug seeking behavior. Moreover, we reveal previously unseen sex-specific trajectories of cocaine-related phasic dopamine responses from acquisition to relapse. We show that males exhibit higher-amplitude phasic dopamine responses, a trait accompanied by a greater resistance to extinguish their cocaine seeking, compared to females. Furthermore, we show that a semi-parametric model of the transition to extinction – using only multivariate patterns of dopamine release and sex as covariates – faithfully recapitulates male-specific vulnerability to persistent cocaine seeking. In conclusion, we present a predictive model of reinstatement behavior that uses information exclusively conveyed by NAc phasic dopamine responses, thus confirming, and actuating the sufficiency of the dopaminergic hypothesis of relapse.